I give this 3 stars because, while it does what you want it to do, it somehow seems a little less than a BJ deserves -- the logo is printed, it has the feeling of being a knock-off, but then again at this price, and the fact that the quality is good enough -- I guess it's a good match for today's batch of BJs in more ways than one; and, at least it isn't grossly over-priced because of the brand name.